American Idol 7 Top 12 Girls Carly Smithson – Video
February 20, 2008 by Jeanne
Carly Smithson made a point of talking about her record deal. Interesting. She sang “Shadow of Your Smile” and it was really good. Sorry y’all. She is sick too. Randy said it was the best vocal of the Top 24. Paula said that every choice she makes involves beautiful inflections. Simon said that he didn’t get it and there’s so much hype about Carly and was expecting more. I wonder if he was extra hard on her because of all the buzz. Hmmm….
Technorati Tags: american idol,american idol 7,american idol top 24,american idol 7 top 24,american idol top 12 girls,american idol 7 top 12 girls,carly smithson,shadow of your smile
I think Simon WAS hard on her because of the whoopla about her earlier record deal. A lot is expected from her because of that.
She does have a beautiful voice, and I think she’s very interesting, but I didn’t like the song she sang. I hope she makes it through to next week, tho.
I’m glad they made her admit to the previous major record deal. I’m not glad that they twisted the truth. That was really unfortunate.
i love carly she has an excellent voice .i hope she makes it to the top three.