Comments on: American Idol 7 Top 6 Performances – April 22, 2008

By: Fan site of Beyonce Knowles, Hilary Duff, Keira Knightley, Jessica Alba, Jessica Biel, Megan Fox, Carrie Underwood, Jordin Sparks, Hayden Panettiere, Cashmere Mafia

Sun, 27 Apr 2008 06:14:10 +0000

David Cook on American Idol 7 Top 6 Finalists Music of the Night…

David Cook was phenomenal in this song. He was a lot different this time around and kept the sensuality of the song instead of drastically changing it into his own. Nonetheless, it was beautifully done.

Judges comments

Randy: Another molten …

By: cookiecrazy97

cookiecrazy97 — Fri, 25 Apr 2008 05:52:29 +0000

how can you criticize david cooks “originality” when david archuletta has taken NO, i mean ABSOLUTELY NONE, risks on his songs. they are all very disney, ballad songs. i would like to try to hear him sing rock (that makes me laugh because he would NEVER pull it off). he is too one-dimensional and boring. DC proved his vocal talents during andrew lloyd webber week. DA should be worried because DC proved he can step in DA’s arena and blow him away. sorry teenieboppers.

By: pk709394

pk709394 — Wed, 23 Apr 2008 04:06:37 +0000

Broadway/LLyod Webber
not a bad choice since most of post AIs tend to head towards Broadway: From Fantasia, Diana DeGarmo to Sanjaya

Syesha Mercado: HOT!!! looks HOT in the Red Dress…HOT performance…all animated and all. Side Note, ladies, see what a great cutting for a dress can do…..no push up bra (the dress is backless) , but amazing cleavage!!!!!

Jason Castro: OK, too much side breathing, i think he needs to take some lessons on how the breathe when singing….Funny how the how time he was singing the song, i was imagining how Brooke White would sound sing the same song. FASHION NO NO, black songs with a white suit/shoes

Brooke White: Yeah, Brooke should have done Memories….in the middle of it…her voice was strained and sounds like she was singing, not good. ok, what was Paula smokin’ tonight….did all 3 judges gave her props a few weeks ago for staring over again. I agree that she was smart to re-start when she forgot the lyrics, i think if she didn’t mention it, no one would have known

David Archuleta: Can someone please go an adjust his tie for him, the crookedness is buggin’ me. I actually liked the way the song was arranged, and liked the performance, no sure why Simon said it was his weakest performance.

Carly Smithson: Didn’t like it, think the Simon T-shirt was tacky…no need for that!

David Cook: Oh, what happen to his “originality”? hmmmmmmmmmmm Don’t think he can actually sing, poor guy ran out of breath on the last note……

Favorite Performance: David Archuleta
Bottom 3: Jason Castro, Brooke White, Carly Smithson
Going Home: Brooke White

Till next week kids!

By: sherry

sherry — Wed, 23 Apr 2008 01:40:45 +0000

David Cook FTW! He was amazing and definitely nailed the sensual side of things. *fans self*

By: angie

angie — Wed, 23 Apr 2008 01:20:32 +0000

DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!! DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!! DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!! DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!

By: katy

katy — Wed, 23 Apr 2008 01:15:31 +0000

DAVID COOK! WOW! not only can that man sing rock but definately proved to us how well rounded he is. i could see him performing in broadway right now. if this eventually turns into a battle of the davids…david c. could easily sing in the same style of david a. and blow him away. he just proved it tonight. i think syesha, carly and david cook stole the show tonight. jason and brooke were train wrecks and david a. was his boring, predictable, not moving on stage, self.