Idol Face Off - Open Arms
It’s Friday which normally means there is a Face Off with Clay Aiken in it… and today’s no different. Clay faces off against Elliott Yamin. This is a hot one because both American Idol cuties sing “Open Arms” in very different styles. I love them both!
Which will you choose?
Clay Aiken
Elliott Yamin
Which Idol Do You Have Open Arms For?
Tags: clay aiken, elliott yamin, face off, open arms, vote, poll, video, idol stalker, idol, american, american idol
Related Stories
POSTED IN: Clay Aiken, Elliott Yamin, Idol Face Off, Polls, Videos
200 opinions for Idol Face Off - Open Arms
Bev
Nov 9, 2007 at 4:15 am
oh oh, I cry foul Jeanne! lol I love both these singers!
I voted for Clay but Elliot is a close second.
Manon
Nov 9, 2007 at 5:06 am
Both guy are good, but Clay voice his so perfect it why he had my vote.
pat b
Nov 9, 2007 at 6:55 am
Nothing beats the pure tone of Clay’s voice. Elliott was good but Clay was fantastic.
faith
Nov 9, 2007 at 7:05 am
Wow, Clay wins. With no backing except piano he is amazing!
Kim
Nov 9, 2007 at 7:19 am
I love Elliott and I think he has gotten even better since his Idol days but there is no way I can give my vote to anyone but Clay on this one . Even though I know he is a good singer I am always startled and thrilled by the the tone and clarity of his voice .
Becky
Nov 9, 2007 at 8:23 am
Clays voice just melts me on the insides!! Every note slides down like honey!!! He wins this one by a land slide for me!!! Eliott was good but Clay is incredible!!!
anonymous
Nov 9, 2007 at 9:15 am
I love Clay and I love Elliott. Two of the best voices from American Idol, I just love to listen to both of them. Elliott is my favorite from season 5 and I voted for him like mad. But Clay is my favorite from any season. I think there is a very good chance he will remain, not only the best to date, but the best they ever have.
There are many singers that have come out of AI that I think are really, really great, like Elliott but Clay is still the one.
Barb G
Nov 9, 2007 at 9:20 am
ELIOTT*ELLIOTT*ELLIOTT
Thanks for the goosebumps, again!
nanassetta
Nov 9, 2007 at 9:48 am
ELLIOTT YAMIN for sure!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Roni
Nov 9, 2007 at 10:08 am
Elliott was one of my faves during his season. His performance of “Open Arms” was good but he had the good fortune of having a band backing him up. And in my opinion, while I do love his the sound of his voice, he doesn’t have the vocal strength that Clay has.
Clay had only the piano accompanying him and yet, he still sounded fantastic. With the clarity of his voice, the power and the range of his vocals, Clay’s performance soars. Beautiful!!!
FrankEY
Nov 9, 2007 at 10:11 am
Without ANY DOUBT, ELLIOTT. He IS the
BEST singer to ever come from AI.
bjstur
Nov 9, 2007 at 10:22 am
Elliott is a good singer. Clay is a great singer.
Ging
Nov 9, 2007 at 10:31 am
I Love the voice of Elliott Yamin
The videos don’t work…do not remember Clay’s version, so Elliott Gets my Vote
Ging
Nov 9, 2007 at 10:36 am
Ok got the Videos to work…
ELLIOTT ELLIOTT ELLIOTT
BEST BEST BEST !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Love the richness and vibrato in Elliott Voice !!
carolyn
Nov 9, 2007 at 10:54 am
I wish I could have heard both with a full orchestra, but I listened carefully for just the voicee. Clay kept on pitch and finished all notes, so my vote goes to Clay.
carolyn
Nov 9, 2007 at 10:55 am
I wish I could have heard both with a full orchestra, but I listened carefully for just the voice. Clay kept on pitch and finished all notes, so my vote goes to Clay.
edited for typo
Efan2
Nov 9, 2007 at 11:26 am
Gotta go with Elliott. The vibrato, the power in his voice is amazing! Clay’s is nice but just doesn’t give me goose bumps.
deedee
Nov 9, 2007 at 11:28 am
Clay!!
Jess
Nov 9, 2007 at 11:30 am
CLAY ALL THE WAY! No one comes close and with these two videos it shows.Sorry Elliott, I was never a fan.
Jeanne'
Nov 9, 2007 at 11:31 am
I was wondering, when they would do this comparison. I have watch these performances many times before this, and to me Elliott’s unique tone( whether an orchestra, or piano), is so much richer, and to me sings with much more conviction. He has type 1 diabetis, and basically deaf in the right hear. This performance was, right after the go home visit. He was absoluetly exhausted, and had to come back & learn the songs, for the final 3. With all that said, “Elliott gets my vote, because he sang it from his heart & put a soulful spin on the end. Clays end was not as tasty”!! And that’s the truth!
Linda
Nov 9, 2007 at 11:37 am
Apples and oranges. Clay has a beautiful voice. Has a lovely broadway type sound…BUT Elliott Yamin has soul like no other. My vote is for Elliott. He has a rich texture to his voice and conveys each song with passion.
jean
Nov 9, 2007 at 11:38 am
Well, this is the least favorite of all the idol perfromances Clay did, still I prefer it to Elliot purely because of the vibrato.
Elliot has that Josh Groban vibrato thing going and it unappealing to me. A little vibrato is a good thing. Too much is too much. He has a nice tone, but it gets overwhelmed by you know what.
Nan
Nov 9, 2007 at 11:51 am
Clay’s performance was at the beginning of the Hollywood eliminations, and he hadn’t even had the advantage of working with the singing instructors of AI. He has the most amazing tone, and God given voice I have ever heard, and while I like Elliot, there is clearly no comparison. Clay all the way.
Kathy
Nov 9, 2007 at 11:56 am
Simon Cowell got it right. Elliott Yamin is the best male vocalist ever from American Idol.
Barb T.
Nov 9, 2007 at 11:59 am
I really like Elliott and I hope he has a very successful career. Elliott did an admirable job on the song but for me personally this is one of those Clay songs that Clay now owns.
Jenna
Nov 9, 2007 at 12:30 pm
Clay’s voice is just so much stronger and pure than Elliott’s. With some studio help, Elliott did well on his cd, but Clay needs no such help from anything. He will remain the best voice and personality to ever grace Idol’s stage.
Simon’s nasty remark was simply one more dig at Clay. He will never get over backing the wrong horse.
Maryn
Nov 9, 2007 at 1:05 pm
It’s Clay all the way. He is just stupendous, and I don’t think anyone will ever be his equal on Idol.
Elliott has a decent voice, but it just doesn’t have the power and range of Clay.
Jess
Nov 9, 2007 at 1:14 pm
“Well, this is the least favorite of all the idol perfromances Clay did, still I prefer it to Elliot purely because of the vibrato.
Elliot has that Josh Groban vibrato thing going and it unappealing to me. A little vibrato is a good thing. Too much is too much. He has a nice tone, but it gets overwhelmed by you know what.”
This was exactly it for me jean, I couldn’t handle the vibrato. it was too goat like for me.
philly
Nov 9, 2007 at 1:16 pm
CLAY!!!!!!! He just sounds so pure and clear and every note is dead on! I thought his performance was amazing!
However Elliot also has a good voice… I thought one of the best ones from season five. Yet the power and range is just no comparision to Mr. Aiken.
Elliot can really sing.
But Clay can really SANG!!
-philly
Swoon
Nov 9, 2007 at 1:31 pm
Although Clay sounds nice, his voice does nothing for me. LOVE Elliott’s version, full of soul and depth
!!!.
Melissa
Nov 9, 2007 at 1:32 pm
My vote is for Elliott. While Clay undeniably has a beautiful voice, in this instance I prefer the richness and depth of Elliott’s.
DoraED
Nov 9, 2007 at 1:36 pm
I agree that this face off is like comparing apples and oranges. Both men have very beautiful voices, which makes comparing the two practically impossible. Their voices are just too distinctly different.
imthesame
Nov 9, 2007 at 2:12 pm
Wow, I noticed that some of the Clay fans feel about Clay the way I feel about Elliott. I believe that Elliott has the most beautiful voice in the history of the world and I haven’t read much of the Clay fan stuff, but it appears some of you feel that way about Clay. My personal reaction is that Clay lovingly caresses us with his voice and he does it on purpose - Elliott opens up his mouth and these beautiful sounds come out and he is just finding out what this voice can do and what it does to listeners. In other words - Clay sounds planned, Elliott sounds soulfully honest and incredibly beautiful. I vote Elliott.
Tara
Nov 9, 2007 at 2:26 pm
Clay, Planned? whoo boy. Noone is more Naturally gifted and than Clay, Elliot is rather mundane in comparison
Jacob
Nov 9, 2007 at 2:28 pm
BWAH HA! Goat BOY SINGS!!!!! seriously people think Elliot can sing. I don’t like either but Clay blows goatboy away!
Nan
Nov 9, 2007 at 3:02 pm
Jenna said,
“He will remain the best voice and personality to ever grace Idol’s stage.
Simon’s nasty remark was simply one more dig at Clay. He will never get over backing the wrong horse.”
Couldn’t agree more Jenna. He (Simon) was asked once in an interview (after AI2) if he would ever lie. He said “Yes”, and didn’t surprise me a bit. He sure lied about Elliot. Chris Daughtry (from his own season) is better than Elliot. But NO ONE in any season, has ever even come CLOSE to Clay (doubt anyone will either), and that’s a fact.
Too bad they didn’t send Clay instead of Kelly to the World Idol competition; he would have blown them all out of the water, and brought the championship back here to America.
Taratova
Nov 9, 2007 at 3:15 pm
Elliott has a voice that is unique in that when you hear Elliott his voice is a distinct sound unlike anyone else. His tone is new and rare. For me Elliott is a gift because his voice has energy, a tone that gives me chills, and a creative way to make the song real. Elliott gets my vote.
MrsWhosits
Nov 9, 2007 at 3:23 pm
I’m not an Idol watcher (does that get me boo’d from both camps? LOL) I became an Elliott fan after his CD release and have since backtracked to see his AI performances. As someone else mentioned, the 2 singers are apples & oranges. I *think* what PP meant by Clay sounding more “planned” is that he sounds more “polished” Clay sings beautifully. Elliott is more raw & gritty, which for me, is more appealing. Also, while I have not had the pleasure of seeing Clay in concert. I have seen Elliott. He’s one of the few artist that actually sounds better live, especially during acoustic sets. Additionally, he brings such a passion to his performance. I recently read someone describe one of his performances as “sex on a stick”. I wholeheartedly agree. Not scattered rose petals on the bed sex, but more the hot, pounding, sweaty kind.
Josh
Nov 9, 2007 at 4:34 pm
Elliot is a nice guy, I just can’t get into his voice. It sounds weak to me. Clay makes the hair on my neck stand on end. His voice is rich and make me pay attention. Elliot is good, but I tend to drift away when listening.
clara Boyer
Nov 9, 2007 at 5:44 pm
Elliott is the best!!!
Nancy
Nov 9, 2007 at 5:52 pm
ELLIOTT YAMIN OF COURSE!
RainE
Nov 9, 2007 at 5:58 pm
I love Elliott’s voice ,no other like it around. It’s just too bad that whenever there is a poll that all the immature haters have to come out..I thought the poll was supposed to be to state your favourite ,not to degrade the other..Sad isn’t it?
Cathy
Nov 9, 2007 at 6:36 pm
No question — Elliott is absolutely the best. Such a richness and texture to his voice, infused with soul and passion. I’ve heard him live and he certainly doesn’t need any “studio help,” he’s the real deal. His acoustic sets will take your breath away. His voice stirred my soul from the start and I never get tired of listening to him.
Carol
Nov 9, 2007 at 6:37 pm
They are Both very talented, but Clay wins this for me. I voted for Elliott every week because I thought he deserved to win. Love his voice and adore Elliott.
Just like Elliott fans love his voice, that is how Clay fans feel about Clay. Clay has a voice like no other. Although Clay will always be at the top of my list for singers, Elliott comes in a close second. Clay all the way.
artymom
Nov 9, 2007 at 6:39 pm
Sorry, it’s a no brainer for me…Elliott. Clay has a beautiful voice but no where near the texture, richnes, soul or “gives me chills” factor. Interesting that so may Clay people posted here but Elliott seems to be winning the poll.
artymom
Nov 9, 2007 at 6:41 pm
Sorry, it’s a no brainer for me…Elliott. Clay has a beautiful voice but nowhere near the texture, richness, soul or “gives me chills” factor as Elliott. Interesting that so many Clay people posted here but Elliott seems to be winning the poll.
luci
Nov 9, 2007 at 7:18 pm
Every day is Clay day for me! His pitch is always on, his tones are clear and beautiful and he has such power!!!
rm
Nov 9, 2007 at 7:34 pm
Elliott wins this battle. I LOVE Clay AND Elliott, but for me, the depth & soul of Elliotts’ voice gives the song meaning/feeling. These 2 men are the ONLY Am. Idol contestants that caused me to vote repeatedly.
Diane
Nov 9, 2007 at 7:34 pm
Hmmm. Elliot sounded a bit off to me, actually, although I usually think he’s a pretty good singer. I had forgotten how Clay looked back then, but man — what a voice. He got my vote.
psbintl
Nov 9, 2007 at 7:42 pm
This really is no contest. From Elliot’s opening notes his tone was so weak compared to Clay’s. He does not come even close to the power and exact on pitch and tone that Clay has. But that is ok because no other male singer has come close to matching Clay’s vocal talent, absolutely no one.
It is what it is.
Clay all the way with this one, by a landslide.
:)
AngELL
Nov 9, 2007 at 7:43 pm
Elliott knocks me off my feet…I love Clay but Elliott has me body and soul!
vitaljoanne
Nov 9, 2007 at 7:58 pm
Clay gets my vote
M.S. Lady
Nov 9, 2007 at 7:59 pm
I use music therapy for part my treatment for Multiple Sclerosis. Another of my brain, has somehow been activated into use. I have 10 legions in my brain. Thankfully, at this time I am in remission.
To get to my point, I am a big Clay Aiken fan. I have listened to Clay’s version of “Open Arms”, and then I listened to Elliott Yamin’s version. What I ear & feel is that Clay’s version sounds great, and shows promise. But, something does not connect, or give me a feeling of completeness. When I listen to Elliott’s version, I trully feel it, and it fills me up,& my brain is happier!
Maybe on a different song, I would feel differently. I have discovered with my therapy, that Elliott’s voice holds magic for how I feel. This is extremely interesting to me, because I am such Clay fan.
Elliott is now, my drug of choice! My brain & body are calling all the shots. This man is extremely special!! Like some untapped healing well. This disease is not curable, but I am not afraid, as long as Elliott Yamin’s music is in my life. Sorry Clay, I am hopelessly devoted the Mr. Elliott. Keep my medicine coming! You make me feel so much better!
vitaljoanne
Nov 9, 2007 at 8:00 pm
Clay aiken’s pure voice wins my vote
Linda
Nov 9, 2007 at 8:00 pm
Something is wrong with this poll. The numbers are going backwards.
Rachel
Nov 9, 2007 at 8:03 pm
“Clay’s voice is just so much stronger and pure than Elliott’s. With some studio help, Elliott did well on his cd, but Clay needs no such help from anything. He will remain the best voice and personality to ever grace Idol’s stage.
Simon’s nasty remark was simply one more dig at Clay. He will never get over backing the wrong horse.”
HAHAHAHAHA. Studio help?
Im guessing you’ve never seen him live.
He sounds BETTER live than he does in the studio.
of course, your opinion doesnt matter. Elliott is the best.
just letting you know, you sound stupid when you say such stupid things. :)
Thanks.
As Simon once said “Elliott, we have had 5 seasons, and I think, potentially, you are the best male vocalist we’ve had.”
holler.
:)
jenna
Nov 9, 2007 at 8:23 pm
Rachel, you are so wrong. I DID hear Elliott live, and he is simply not up to par when compared to Clay Aiken in a live concert. He also does not have the stage presence of Clay.
He is ok, and sings some ballads very nicely, but that is it. I do wish him well, as he appears to be a nice guy.
Clay owns the stage, has a quick wit, endearing personality, and the best live voice I have ever heard.
M.S. Lady
Nov 9, 2007 at 8:41 pm
This is about the song, Open Arms. People need to try to be fair, and do the poll. This is getting to be hurtful, and that’s not even the point!
Open your ears, & really listen to the song. I did & I told the real truth.
I understand people defending your favorite singer, but do it peacefully. I love Clay Aiken, but it’s Elliott, who has touched me, with this song!
Robin
Nov 9, 2007 at 8:49 pm
I like Elliot a lot. Voted for him his season. But, based on this performence alone, I don’t think this was a very strong performence by Elliot. And, I remember back when I saw him perform it on AI.. I thought the same thing then. It was not a great performence. I do think Elliot does have a very good voice. I enjoy his singing very much.
But, for this song, what is posted here. Clay wins for me! His voice just oozes passion, and it is so rich, and he gives me goosebumps. A wonderful performence by Clay. Clay has got the best voice of anyone to come through American Idol for 6 straight seasons. He just blows everyone else away.
Clay is the winner of this face-off.
Jackie
Nov 9, 2007 at 8:50 pm
I don’t need to defend Clay as his voice is outstanding to me and hearing him live is so much more. I smile and sometimes cry at his voice and how he makes me feel when I hear him. He sings from his heart and he has my heart.
Sue
Nov 9, 2007 at 8:52 pm
American Idol is over, peeps. Lighten up. Both of these men are doing great and have nice careers ahead of them. I love both voices. Voted for both of them. But only Elliott caused me to vote non-stop for two hrs. every week. His voice is a gift and touches my soul to the depths.
Joanne
Nov 9, 2007 at 9:00 pm
Ok, first off there is NO ONE in my opinion that can do that song like Steve Perry …..he has a unique voice and for me that song will forever be associated with him .
Having said that Clay does a phenominal job with that song and I enjoyed it even better when he performed it in concert with Kelly Clarkson too.
Elliott does a great job as well , but still cannot top Clay , so Clay will get my vote here !!!
Kate
Nov 9, 2007 at 9:09 pm
Clay, hands down. Elliot doesn’t even compare here. He’s got a good voice but this song…just no.
deedee
Nov 9, 2007 at 9:09 pm
CLAY - ALL THE WAY!!!!!
Mariam
Nov 9, 2007 at 9:17 pm
Clay’s voice is so pure and rich… to me Elliot always sounds like he is singing through his nostrils (sorry Elliot!)
pat dawn
Nov 9, 2007 at 9:18 pm
eliott voice is pleasant but clay aiken voice is much more powerful and pure. his voice can touch your heart like nobody else. he is unique.
Rachel
Nov 9, 2007 at 9:29 pm
LOL
I dont think so Jenna.
You are obviously mistaking Elliott for someone else.
Hes DEFINITELY much better live than in the studio.
:)
Hes much better than Clay
kthanks :)
RJC
Nov 9, 2007 at 9:44 pm
Clay without a doubt. He sang this song better and he can sing anything and does. Soul, Pop and Country. He warms my heart.
Elliott is so talented and seems like a genuine, down to earth young man also. I wish him the very best in everything he does.
Jessica
Nov 9, 2007 at 9:54 pm
LOL whatever Rachel, I agree with Jenna.
Clay gets my vote here. So much better than Elliot .
SimonSucketh
Nov 9, 2007 at 9:57 pm
I hate this song, but I gave it a listen by both men and there’s no comparison - Clay’s was pure, rich and beautiful. I love Elliott’s new album and think he’s very talented, but he didn’t sing for toffee on that song. I heard at least two notes that were completely off pitch, and others that sounded thin and weak. I remember wincing the night he sang it too, because he did far better just about every other performance.
Nan
Nov 9, 2007 at 10:11 pm
RACHEL,
WHERE ARE YOUR MANNERS? IT’S NOT NICE TO CALL SOMEONE “STUPID” JUST BECAUSE THEY HAVE A DIFFERING OPINION. SHAME ON YOU.
YOU REALLY SHOULD APOLOGIZE TO JENNA FOR THAT AND ALSO TELLING HER THAT HER OPINION DOESN’T MATTER. AS A MATTER OF FACT HER OPINION MATTERS MUCH MORE THAN YOURS SINCE SHE’S GOT IT RIGHT, AND WHILE ELLIOT SINGS VERY WELL, NOT EVERYBODY AGREES WITH YOUR ASSESSMENT IN THIS CASE. PAULA TOLD CLAY AFTER THIS PERFORMANCE THAT HE HAD THE MOST AMAZING TONE, AND BETWEEN THAT AND HIS THREE OCTAVE RANGE AND POWER, HE HAS THE MOST PHENOMENAL, GLORIOUS, GOD GIVEN INSTRUMENT IN THE WHOLE ENTERTAINMENT BUSINESS. NO QUESTION OR COMPETITION. HE’S SIMPLY THE BEST THERE IS ANYWHERE. NOW WHY DON’T YOU BE NICE, LIKE YOUR MOMMA PROBABLY TAUGHT YOU, AND APOLOGIZE TO JENNA?
faith
Nov 9, 2007 at 10:21 pm
Wow, who let all the children out to vote tonight?
Neither Clay nor Elliot would be too happy with the name calling!
patti
Nov 9, 2007 at 10:21 pm
I am not going to argue who is best.. not fair to either. They both are the best to come out of Idol. But being a long time follower of Clay, I will naturally choose him. Elliot is a talented and sweet guy, who like Clay has transformed himself to a much more appealing performer! Both performances were when they were raw and new to the who Idol thing.
Elliott is growing and I wish him the best. But Clay is a master in concert, controlling his voice and his audience, have seen many great singers but he is the best. A truly unique individual in his heart and his song.
jo
Nov 9, 2007 at 10:31 pm
As in a couple of other Clay face-offs here, I think so much depends on the taste of the viewer, and whether there is a preference for a tenor or a baritone. Fortunately for Clay, he handles both handily. This song, I believe, is totally in his tenor ranges, and Elliott is singing it in a baritone range. His version is warm, sweet and appealing, but it lacks the power this song calls for and the arrangement doesn’t provide a challenge for his voice. When at the end of a line Clay hold the high note or raises it. Elliott lets it float down. I really enjoy Elliott singing, I just think he should not sing challenging scores where he will be forced to change the notes, as he has done here.
As far as Clay’s voice recognition, several persons whose professional experience is respected have stated that his voice is immediately recognizable, and that it is one way the greats are identified.
Not only did Simon put his eggs in Ruben’s basket but, if I recall, he sold his rights to Clay’s contract (to Simon Fuller ??) as he was so sure there was no money to be made from Clay. He resents every success and every dime. Sorry about that, Simon.
cookie
Nov 9, 2007 at 11:47 pm
I thought Elliott was the best singer by far on AI5. But how can you compare him to a voice like Clay Aiken’s. His power and range are phenomenal and he is exciting. I would like to hear any singer attempt “All is Well” covering 21/2 octaves the way Clay does. That would prove a lot right there and it would be very interesting. I’d love to hear the famous J.Timberlake attempt it. Now that would be a contest.
Donna
Nov 10, 2007 at 2:28 am
Having heard Clay sing this song many times it’s interesting to see the original time on AI again. Just Clay and piano music, that voice just soared. So much emotion and yet so much control. I anticipated when Elliot sang it on the show, and felt he was good, but after having already seen Clay do it on the show, in such a bare background and still knock it out — well there just isn’t a comparison. I like Elliot’s voice and wished him well on the show and since. But on one compares to Clay singing live, whether on a show or in concert. I just close my eyes and it goes all through you.
toby's mom
Nov 10, 2007 at 3:43 am
I love it when both artists have such passionate fan bases. It just shows how talented and charismatic both of them are. I’m going with Clay on this one and I’m basing that on the fact that I have never cared for the fast jerky vibrato of Elliott’s (although it’s a little better today so he has worked on controlling it some). Clay’s voice is just to clear, so pure, so powerful, and has such a beautiful tone to it.
Also, if I remember correctly, Simon said Elliott “just may” be the best male voice on Idol so far. Puts just a little different spin on it than “is” the best male voice. Also, we all know how Simon likes to “stab” Clay any chance he can because Clay made Simon and Randy look like idiots on more than one occasion. JMO though.
Roni
Nov 10, 2007 at 5:46 am
I just viewed the montage of Clay with music accompanied by his demo recorded version of “Open Arms”. That was recorded pe-AI and man, he sounded so fabulous already. Clay’s got the voice! Distinct, pure, beautiful, crystal clear, brilliant…….I could go on with the praises but I guess you’d get what I mean.
clara Boyer
Nov 10, 2007 at 5:56 am
The true spin is that Simon said that to Elliott AFTER Clay had already been heard. So IMO he definately meant that Elliott is the best male vocalist on the show. EVER!! But, really don’t like mincing words. Clay is loved by many, and so is Elliott.
wishes
Nov 10, 2007 at 6:33 am
Elliott is my choice all the way.
It’s not surprising that due to the differences in the stages they were performing on - Clay seemed the more powerful singer. Still his voice became piercing and not in a good way for me. I’ve turned Elliott up to full volume in my car and his voice never hurts my ears. On this piece of music - turn Elliott’s way up and you’ll see who’s got the better voice.
Conversely, I’d like to hear Elliott’s version without the full orchastra. I could listen to him sing acapella (sp) forever.
beth
Nov 10, 2007 at 6:42 am
Two good singers on a great song. Have to cast my vote for Clay though. He has a special, powerful voice.
Becky
Nov 10, 2007 at 7:13 am
Slimon was a jackass the way he treated Clay at times! anyone could see how lame his comments were after Clay blew the roof off the joint.. Clay was the stand out to me from the very beginning he had that special drawing power with his all consuming voice and magnetic stage presence.. Clay is a powerhouse live..and noone from AI in my opinion will have top that instrument that he has been abundantly blessed with. He is filet mignon compared to many ..His voice is succulent and so tender..every note you chew on slides down with tender ease.. The man takes my breath away!!!
GreatVibeGirl
Nov 10, 2007 at 7:52 am
Elliott sings with feeling and soul that gets to the heart.Elliott can create more to a song and leave the same ole style behind. Clay is more tame and just lacks soul. Clay sings it just like the original song.
Plus Stevie Wonder’s style in singing is awesome to me so naturally I like Elliott and his vibrato.. just like the vibrato that Elvis used on the song I can’t help falling in love with you. Elvis was all vibrato on that song and I loved it..So I love vibrato.And Elliott’s vibrato has great vibrations, soul and life.
CG
Nov 10, 2007 at 8:28 am
My vote goes to Clay.
But at least this time Elliot provided some real competition. Most of these face-offs are no brainers - but Elliot is really GOOD. I can at least understand why someone might prefer his style to Clay’s, and both men have fantastic voices.
clara Boyer
Nov 10, 2007 at 8:34 am
I just listened to Clay’s Bridge Over Troubled Water. He definately shows “soul” in that song. Good job! “Soul” is what I love to hear, that is why Elliott will always be my favorite.
Mari
Nov 10, 2007 at 10:14 am
I did not hear Elliott sing this originally. I really liked his rendition, although at times his voice wavered quite a bit. Elliott was my favorite on his season-he deserved to win. I think he has a great voice and I wish him lots of good things, album sales, etc.
However, in this song, it is the power and clarity in Clays voice that attracted me and kept me enthralled until the final notes. The range of this mans voice is amazing, and the way he sustains the notes without losing any power is still amazing.
So Elliott, keep it going, because you are extremely good-
But for this song, Clay comes across much more for me.
jean
Nov 10, 2007 at 11:51 am
Clay has so much more power and range to his voice. Someone said it well:
Elliott is a good singer, Clay is a GREAT singer, truer words were never spoken.
bb
Nov 10, 2007 at 11:51 am
I thought for once, there could be a poll that doesnt resemble a”Kat” fight. Here we have 2 extraordinarily talented singers, and all we are supposed to do is cast a vote as to which one we have “open Arms ” for, not Say who you like , then rip the other one apart. Now I know why I stay away from garbage like this. Grow up peeps, There’s room for both Clay AND Elliott in this world.
Now as for me, I prefer ELLIOTT.
mode
Nov 10, 2007 at 12:00 pm
Clay Aiken Proves why he is the Best Idol To ever grace the stage. Sorry elliot ( and Fans) Not even close.
bjstur
Nov 10, 2007 at 12:26 pm
Simon also said Clay was the best male vocalist. Simon’s opinions dont mean much. He knows very little about music and vocal ability. It all comes down to what you like. Music is very subjective.
Melissa
Nov 10, 2007 at 12:28 pm
This was my least favorite song that Elliott performed on AI5. I only started watching season 5. But I’ve listened to Clay. Boy, both men are soooo different!!!!! Clay’s voice is clear and strong. He has a nice tone and his range is broad. And he is a tenor. Elliott’s voice is a bit raspy, with a honey baritone sound. And he has a nice tone too. One is not better than the other; both men have great voices. We have to remember this is a subjective vote. So be nice already gesh!!!!!
Rachel
Nov 10, 2007 at 12:39 pm
LOL.
Im not apologizing for anything.
Thats my opinion.
Elliott sounds good only in studio?
psht.
and yes, Simon may have told Clay that, BUT, Elliott was in a DIFFERENT season, a season AFTER Clays, which tends to make it lean more towards Elliott.
Elliott is the best.
Always will be.
Clays good, but, hes no Elliott.
kadee
Nov 10, 2007 at 1:03 pm
Wow, all this poll seems to be proving is that both Clay and Elliot have some pretty rude fans!
Debbie
Nov 10, 2007 at 1:13 pm
Now I am going to sound like Simon but . . .
when I close my eyes and listen to both it is Clay Aiken’s voice that stands out. He makes you want to stop, look and take in every word. I enjoy listening to Elliott and really like the songs he has on the radio. As for looks, Clay was a cutie then and both have matured to handsome young men today.
Rachel
Nov 10, 2007 at 1:16 pm
lol.
I dont think im “rude”
I think its rude to say Elliott only sounds good in the studio though.
Im proving something.
Thats like me saying Clay only sounds good when the studio enhances his voice.
please.
Rachel
Nov 10, 2007 at 1:16 pm
lol.
I dont think im “rude”
I think its rude to say Elliott only sounds good in the studio though.
Im proving something.
Thats like me saying Clay only sounds good when the studio enhances his voice.
please.
Anne
Nov 10, 2007 at 1:23 pm
Ditto Debbie
Troodles
Nov 10, 2007 at 1:23 pm
It’s interesting to see everyones opinion. Some say they like Elliott’s conviction and some like Clay’s pure sound. Personally I love Clay’s sound and conviction. Elliott sounds to me like he’s trying to hard and I always found it painful to listen to him, but to each their own. Thank God for differences.
clara Boyer
Nov 10, 2007 at 1:24 pm
I think this discussion has really shown that we all love “our” guy. Some for Clay, some for Elliott. (Two T.s) I find it interesting that the most rabid Clay fans spell Elliott with one T. That is just an observation, not an insult. Believe me when I say, Elliott has rabid fans also, I am one, I confess.LOL
DeDeBe
Nov 10, 2007 at 1:46 pm
I don’t think that spelling Elliott’s name wrong has anything to do with what kind of a Clay fan someone is. Elliott’s fans are going to vote for him. Clay’s fans are going to vote for him. Its pretty simple.
They are both good singers. I prefer Clay.
Tim
Nov 10, 2007 at 1:51 pm
Clay gets my vote!
Timbidd
Nov 10, 2007 at 2:04 pm
Like clay but Elliott wins this for me.
May
Nov 10, 2007 at 2:42 pm
Can`t believe there are still people who believe every word Simon says, Simon only cares about himself and his own pocket. Both these young men deserve their fans, and success.
Having said that no one has every impressed me like Clay. He is a wonderful singer, but not all are going to hear it. I am glad I do.
bj28
Nov 10, 2007 at 3:32 pm
I like both of the singers today, my main opinion is the strength, conviction, purity, and the ability of Clay while singing to hold the mike facing the floor and still be able to “carry” the last notes of a song thru out the arena that he is singing in, over an orchestra, as if it didn’t matter. He has a voice that can and will be heard by many. He has my vote, I do like Elliott’s voice however and wish the man no hard knocks.
Robin
Nov 10, 2007 at 3:54 pm
Ok.. I did what some suggested. I closed my eyes and listened to both versions. I also turned the volume way up. And, still.. Clay’s version is the winner for me. Again, I do like Elliott a lot. He was my favorite his season. And, I hope he has a wonderful, and long career.
But….. on this song, there just is no comparison. To me.. and yes, music opinions are subjective.. so this is just my opinion. But, to me.. Elliott sings, this song very nice. But, that’s it.. it’s just nice. And, in my opinion, there is nothing different or unique about the song.
In arguing with what someone above said.. Clay’s does not sound like the original. He made this song hiw own. Elliott’s is closer to being sung just like the orginal. Nothing is changed up, or reaaranged. Clay’s version has some different arrangement, yet it doesn’t take away from the original.
Clay sings this song with so much feeling and conviction. Where, as I don’t here much feeling coming from Elliott. It really feels like he is just singing the words.
As, I said in my previous post. I do remember not being very impressed by this performence by Elliott when it was first aired on the show. To me it just falls flat, and is very mondane.
My kudos to Clay, for taking a very, very classic song, and breathing new life into it. Ahhhhh.. and those very soulful low notes Clay’s hits throughout the song.. well, they just reach down and curl my toes!!! And, that’s a good thing!
anonymous
Nov 10, 2007 at 6:03 pm
I’m sorry, Clay. As deeply as I love you, and your voice, I could not vote for you on this one.
But, I didn’t vote for Elliot, either.
My only choice was to vote “Equally Bad.”
This is one of the VERY few times that Clay’s voice, no matter how good it is, just isn’t enough. I don’t like his version of this song.
In fact, I don’t like any cover of Open Arms.
IMO, no one should ever sing this song but Steve Perry.
anonymous
Nov 10, 2007 at 6:06 pm
I just saw the comments about spelling Elliott’s name wrong.
Sorry. It was absolutely not intentional.
GreatVibeGirl
Nov 10, 2007 at 6:08 pm
Elliott connected to my soul with his sound. Clay does not. Clay’s voice belongs on Broadway . Elliott’s Voice in my CD collection.
Pat
Nov 10, 2007 at 6:13 pm
i have tried to vote about 20 times, but none of my votes have been counted…what gives???
Sheila
Nov 10, 2007 at 7:04 pm
Elliott all the way. I stopped listening to Clay half way through….. Too Broadway musical, over done for me. Too Barry Manilow. Yes, I know. Barry Manilow has a lot of fans. I am just not one of them. Never will be. Same with Clay. I recognized that he sings well. Just not the manly sexy voice I want to hear. That would be Elliott.
Hannah
Nov 10, 2007 at 8:31 pm
There is no way on earth this was even a contest. The power and tone in Clay’s voice is unmatched. There were nights he was even better than this, but he still wins my vote.
Elliott had some decent outings, and some not so good, but this one was just not outstanding. Very bland, and just ok. Nice guy though.
Simon just said that KNOWING Clay had sung the song, and people would be fuming at his silly remark. He’s still giving Clay digs, and cannot forgive him for being successful, despite his bashing, and his “not looking like a pop star.” I suppose Ruben looked JUST RIGHT.
Jan
Nov 10, 2007 at 9:11 pm
Actually, both were very good. I really like Elliott a lot and always enjoyed him on AI. But I still gotta say given the choice, I prefer Clay’s version and voice over Elliott. Something about the smoothness and purity of Clay’s voice melts my heart like butter. But I truly love Elliott’s version as well. This is probably the closest face-off for me.
clara Boyer
Nov 10, 2007 at 9:16 pm
Someone said it just so right. This is not even a fair contest. Hands down, Elliott’s voice is really so much fuller and soothing than Clay’s on this song. Sorry, Clay sounds clunky and twangy and he usually sounds a little better when he sings. Not so on this one, though. Elliott’s voice is better even than the original on this one, I might add. No one compares to Elliott’s vibrato and he melts me to the core.So, yes, definately, no comparison here.
Joanne
Nov 10, 2007 at 9:24 pm
I would just love to comment & say that from year to year Simon has always stated that there is one certain person that is the best he has ever seen . He even said Clay would win the compitition . Season 3 Simon said Fantasia was the best he has ever seen . They always say the season that they are in is THE best season EVAH . It is to draw in viewers.
That is not to say that Elliott is not phenominal because he is . I was listening to a new Idol radio on the internet and I heard what I thought was a fantastic sounding voice ……It was Elliott . He is good and he should have a great career.
My heart , mind & soul however have been forever captured by Clay Aiken . His voice and his alone makes my spirit soar to hights unimagineable !!!
patti
Nov 10, 2007 at 9:36 pm
Okay I listened one more time, it is obvious to me that like “beauty is in the eyes of the beholder”, so is singing. Actually I think this face off has been more respectful than most. Maybe because both of these guys are just plain talented and nice guys and neither deserve a dig.
But in the end, no ones voice moves me like Clay’s and that feeling is in no way disrespectful of Elliott or his fans.
amused
Nov 10, 2007 at 10:16 pm
Why does anyone bother to vote in any AI poll that has Clay in it? Be happy with your favorite idol and save your time and votes for something that can actually help them. Most of the mates live to sing their praises of Clay and can’t just vote without dissing everyone else in the poll. Let them have their meaningless poll victories (they really don’t have too much else to be happy about) and save yourself the aggravation of reading what they have to say of anyone who isn’t their GOD.
patti
Nov 10, 2007 at 10:37 pm
Amused… I don’t see anyone here really “dissing” anyone. Most of these posts have been very respectful of both singers. Yeah Clay fans are passionate but it seems Elliott fans are equally so. But both seem to be considerate of each other. Perhaps the “dissing” is coming from outsiders who just want to stir up trouble!
Robin
Nov 10, 2007 at 10:42 pm
There hasn’t been hardly any dissing by Clay people. More have dissed Clay from Elliott’s side. Many of the posts here by Clay fans have been very nice about Elliott. Many even have said to like Elliott. Sure, maybe a few have disses, but it hasn’t been the majority. More so from the Elliott fans, doing the dissing. Or as said above, outsiders.
kfc-Canada
Nov 10, 2007 at 10:47 pm
Hmmmmmm,,both cuties sang this in two different styles?? If you could superimpose the songs you’d see that there was no variation in the the delivery of the song at all. Elliott outstretched his arms sideways and Clay extended his to the front. Hmmmmmm not much difference there. So it comes down to voice and sincerity and charisma…and I didn’t feel any charisma from Elliott at all. I felt that he studied Clay’s style and copied it to the final note.
That said…I congratulate all those who voted for Elliott; you stood by your man and that’s all that’s important. He’s a hard-working, credible singer and is focussed on fighting diabetes. Kudos to him. I admire him, too…but, he’s not my guy..he’s yours.
I vote for Clay because his voice is outstanding, his song delivery is excellent and ’sincere’ (and they both sang that word the exact same way) and he projects charisma all the way down to the furthest corner of Lafayetteville Street in Raleigh.
JuneBug
Nov 10, 2007 at 10:49 pm
For the most part Simon’s opinions have been right on the money. But remeber he wanted to vote Kelly Clarkson out of the top 24 and didn’t care for her much until his precious Tymara was voted off. I don’t remeber his exact comments during the debate of keeping her or not but I do remember him putting her picture to the side and saying they would come back to her (Kelly) later. Not very objective where Clay is concerned love, love, love him however I like, like, like Elliott very much. At first I thought I was going to have to vote a tie until Elliott kinda wandered off at the end. Clay gets my vote here. The only person who comes close to Clay in my opinion (and may even be as good) is that Australian Idol Anthony Callea now he’s a real talent to reckoned with.
kfc-Canada
Nov 10, 2007 at 11:03 pm
Well, I listened to both songs again with my eyes closed…to pick up any vibes I might have missed..and..I have to say this is the best performance Elliott ever gave on American Idol. But, it’s obvious that he was influenced by Clay’s style and delivery because Elliott’s delivery is almost identical…and..since Clay sang it first…I stand by what I said.
Oh..and Clay also had a tremelo (or whatevah) at the end of the song…so…guess what…
Kella
Nov 10, 2007 at 11:03 pm
Elliott hit too many bland and slightly off notes to get me to vote for him. Clay was by far the better one on this song.
Robin
Nov 10, 2007 at 11:15 pm
I have a question to about Elliott’s performence. The last four lines.. two of them Elliott did them backwards. Was that on purpose, or did he mix them up? The flow of the end of his performence, is awkward because he sings the wrong line in the wrong place.
joann
Nov 11, 2007 at 6:57 am
Sorry, but Elliott has always sounded so bland to me. He is my LEAST favorite from all seasons.
Clay Aiken, the BEST there ever was and will always be. Truly the AMERICAN IDOL!!
Samantha
Nov 11, 2007 at 9:34 am
I’ve heard them both in concert and I find Clay to be the winner here. His voice just soars effortlessly.
Jackie
Nov 11, 2007 at 10:05 am
Clay has a beautiful voice and sings with his heart. I am very amused by amused and wonder why amused is here. I also admire Eilliott, but Clay is the best.
Nan
Nov 11, 2007 at 11:13 am
I just tried to review them again and got a message “Sorry, this video is no longer available”.
When I clicked on Elliot’s it played as always. What’s up with Clay’s video being unavailable?
GreatVibeGirl
Nov 11, 2007 at 1:18 pm
Elliott has soul.. Clay has a theatrical presence.
Elliott has the real human factor in his phrasing and feeling and energy of a song. As Mr Wonder himself said.. Elliott has that ability to make the song believable. Elliott makes it real!
For me Elliott has that ability to arouse emotions and makes the song live deep in my spirit.
Leida
Nov 11, 2007 at 1:22 pm
Elliott winds hands up. His so much richer that clay’s in thsi ssong
Me
Nov 11, 2007 at 2:17 pm
Oh boy. Let me admit right off the top I’m an Elliott fan, but when I saw that this competition was on the ‘Open Arms’ song I wasn’t very delighted. It’s one of Elliott’s weakest performances, and his voice wasn’t was it should be . Even Kat McPhee said he could barely talk before the show because he had just gotten back from his home visit to Richmond where he hollered his lungs out. He also had to prepare for 3 different songs that night, so his prep time was extremely limited So I figured I better listen to Clay Aiken first. Don’t follow Clay at all, but I’ve heard him sing once or twice. My opinion has always been nice voice, but not my style. I have to say that on this video his pronunciation is so formal as to sound stilted - as though English was not his primary language. It reinforced what I have felt all along about Clay: nice voice but not my style. In summary I would have to say listening to Clay makes me want to stand at attention. Listening to Elliott makes me want to have sex. I vote for Elliott.
nancy
Nov 11, 2007 at 2:19 pm
I started watching AI season 4…Never could understand what everyone saw in Clay Aiken..I now see why they looove him! Clay is really good.
Blech
Nov 11, 2007 at 2:21 pm
Elliot has NO soul, He’s goat boy in looks and sound. Seriously people actually listen to him. I’m no Clay fan but I voted him out of sheer disgust at Elliot.
Nan
Nov 11, 2007 at 2:45 pm
Thanks for fixing the video. This was not Clay’s best performance of this song. I believe he did this rendition because the judges kept telling the contestants not to mimic the original, and make each song your own. I have a CD of demo songs he did when he was a few years younger, and it’s absolutely dynamite. He’s been exceptionally talented for a very long time (way before American Idol). I’ve heard many male “Idols” in my lifetime, but no one compares to Clay. I thank God every day for AI just because I may never have gotten the opportunity to hear that gorgeous, glorious voice. I never tire of listening to him. :) Elliott has a nice voice, but I voted for Clay of course.
sopie
Nov 11, 2007 at 4:13 pm
I have to say that I don’t care for all the
vibrato in Elliott’s voice. Clay gets my vote.
Weez
Nov 11, 2007 at 4:31 pm
I like Clay and his voice but he lacks something Elliott brings.
Elliott brings “heart” to the music..his own.
Cindy
Nov 11, 2007 at 4:33 pm
Elliott beats all others by far!! No contest!
Robin
Nov 11, 2007 at 4:35 pm
I can understand people haveing differences of opinion in the sound of someone’s voice, as far as it being to their liking or not. But.. saying that Clay has ne heart when he sings??? Oh, wow.. I think Clay sings with more heart then anyone out there. He puts all of his heart and soul into everything he sings. That’s what is part of the the huge attraction for Clay fans! Not that Elliott doesn’t have heart in his music either. He does. I don’t hear it in this song though. I am jsut saying. I just don’t get how people listen to this song here, and not hear the emotion in Clay’s voice when he sings.
VOICE EXPERT
Nov 11, 2007 at 5:04 pm
In my conclusion of both singers Clay has control and does give a solid performance with a classic style. It is expected. Many listeners prefer this .
Elliott has a completely different style of singing. His style resonates with great swells of emotion and also a varied delivery in arrangement and version. Many people prefer this style.
Clay has a very classic sound. Elliott a very diverse style in that Elliott gives surprises to his songs.
Depending what style you prefer. Many like the classic sound of the same arrangement sung but a different voice.
Some prefer the song to differ with a creative flow and that takes creative ability with control which is a rare find.
Tek
Nov 11, 2007 at 5:08 pm
While I think Clay does have a clean pure sound, I find Elliott’s voice much more appealing. I love the tone of his voice. As many have said Elliott gives a song heart and he can get down to your soul with his voice, pharasing and tone. Whether one or the other is more technically perfect doesn’t really matter to me. It’s how that singer makes me feel inside and Elliott just touches me like Clay can’t. I don’t think it matters if it’s Open Arms or another song.. I just enjoy more what Elliott brings to a song. Open Arms is no exception.. Elliott all the way.
Lilly
Nov 11, 2007 at 5:17 pm
Elliott’s voice is rich and soulful. I don’t think this song is a good match for either singer, they both have beautiful voices, in their own style. For me, no singer can touch me like Elliott Yamin, no matter what song, I will always like Elliott’s version best, because it’s his voice that stirs my inner most warmest feelings and I think he is beautiful inside and out. Elliott gets my vote!
Nicole
Nov 11, 2007 at 5:51 pm
I vote for Elliott because he has pure emotion in his voice that does touch the heart. He is very talented and I appreciate his gift of music. Clay is good but Elliott brings much more !
shirley
Nov 11, 2007 at 7:05 pm
I have listened to these two versions over and over. Both Elliott and Clay have amazing voices.
I loved Elliott on his season and thought he was cheated…I adored Clay on his season and knew he was cheated.
I have to give this one to Clay because of the clarity of his vocals but Elliott is a very close second.
Nancy
Nov 11, 2007 at 10:26 pm
Nope, Clay is by far more all around talented, And it shows in this song, Elliot has bland, boring style and just does nothing for me, He’s an ordinary vocalist with far too much vabrato.
Tess
Nov 12, 2007 at 12:59 am
Well, I listened again with my eyes closed. Still no contest for me. I like Elliott. I even bought his album. But, I LOVE Clay. Clay’s voice just wraps itself around my heart.
I see Elliott has many fans, and that’s as it should be. He’s a wonderful singer. But for me, it will always be Clay’s voice that makes my heart sing and brings me joy.
rs
Nov 12, 2007 at 2:53 am
Elliot sings the song ok if you like all that goatlike vibrato he manages to put into every song. Clay, on the other hand, has a natural power in his voice and sings it effortlessly. His tone and pitch is perfect and he sings from the heart. Clay all the way for me!
Roxie
Nov 12, 2007 at 4:39 am
Lowering ones self to name calling and making fun of another only makes you look childish, stupid and very immature. Both these young man are deserving of praise without the insults. Choosing YOUR favorite is the topic. Grow up!!
Cathy
Nov 12, 2007 at 4:46 am
My story: I started watching AI in Season 2, and Clay was my favorite. Great voice — I voted for him a couple of times at the finale. I didn’t vote in subsequent seasons until Elliott came along. I voted HUNDREDS of times for him because I believe that he’s someone truly special. I bought CDs from both artists, but Clay’s is gathering dust somewhere after a couple of listens. I got bored with it. I can’t stop listening to Elliott, on the other hand. NEVER get tired of listening to that wonderful, soulful, textured voice.
As for this comparisons of these performances, I didn’t enjoy all the little flourishes that Clay added. I prefer Elliott’s raw, straight, heartfelt delivery. And I’ll have none of that “he wasn’t in his best voice” angle — he was strong as ever on all three songs that night (I Believe to My Soul)!!
Not many artists actually sound BETTER live than in the studio, but Elliott proves that he is a true artist, changing up his songs each time he performs them and infusing them with a sexy, soulful vibe that makes me want MORE.
Lori
Nov 12, 2007 at 6:01 am
I was actually looking forward to hearing Elliot sing as although I have heard lots about him I actually have only heard him sing one song- a current one- which I quite like.
I must say however that I was disappointed in this performance of his. I guess I expected more- of something. I certainly did not see/hear all the emotion that some of you did. Clay’s performance was not as strong as all of the other ones that have been on Face Off but I still think it was better than Elliot’s.
VOICE EXPERT
Nov 12, 2007 at 6:34 am
As I read the comments I can say this with much conviction, Elliott’s fans win for being gracious and on topic. Some Clay fans are rude and some are obnoxious with there verbiage regarding this topic.
Roni
Nov 12, 2007 at 8:54 am
Voice Expert, please do not lump all Clay mates into one general degoratory category. We may be one mind in terms of how we fans feel about Clay’s vocal ability and we think it is out of this world.
However, each individual Clay fans’ personalities are disimiliar to another as I am sure it is the same with Elliott fan base.
Where I am concerned, I have been polite, I have stated my opinion without putting another artist down and I have seen many other Clay fans do the same. Same with fans of Elliott
Sure you would have read some rude, obnoxious comments but as said, they are coming from both sides.
And I do not advocate praising your “idol” and putting the other one down. For the record, I am a Clay fan. For the record too, as I have said in my above statement, I like Elliott, just not more than Clay and in this face-off, I vote Clay and my reasons have also been stated in my previous post.
I have done no name calling, I have not been rude, and I certainly believe, I have not in anyway been obnoxious.
imthesame
Nov 12, 2007 at 9:45 am
I’m trying so hard to be objective. I listened again and the same thing happened that happened before - heaven help me I don’t understand it. I listened to the lovely voice and polished presentation of Clay and thought, how pretty is his tone, how sweet his presentation - very, very good. Then I listened to Elliott and I started sobbing with emotion - the sound of his voice just flattens me into goo - there’s nothing I can do about it - my emotional reaction is so odd, but when I recover I think there must be something going on here - Elliott is a vocal miracle for me - I have no strength to even evaluate what I’m listening to, I just love him and that’s all I know. I vote Elliott - can I vote more than once?
sasha
Nov 12, 2007 at 10:35 am
Elliott fan here. I liked Clay’s better. But to be fair, the audio on Elliott’s video is very bad. I listen to it on mp3, and a different video, and it’s just beautiful.
No one’s voice has EVER moved me like Elliott’s does. Listening to him is PURE BLISS.
Nora
Nov 12, 2007 at 10:47 am
Clay is the best! His voice is pure and sweet, unadulterated. He’s excellent. He has a passion and an energy that comes across in every note he sings. Every note that comes out of his very soul is perfection itself. I am not putting down Elliot, he has a good voice and he can sing, but Clay creates a magic when he sings that is a gift we don’t see often. That is why he has such an immense following. His fans come in all ages and gender and from all over the world.
Jen
Nov 12, 2007 at 10:55 am
I think Elliott is a good singer but I can’t stand the bleating vibrato from any singer. Daughtrey does that too. I like Josh Groban but don’t like it when I can hear vibrato like that. Elliott is a very sweet guy but I don’t see sexy with him. I wish both Clay and Elliott well. They are very talented.
Debbie
Nov 12, 2007 at 12:54 pm
Dear Voice Expert - As a huge Clay Aiken, I have to agree with you. LOL! Some of Clay’s fans do much more harm for his career than good. They attach any negative comments no matter how well intended and turn “would-be” or “once-were” fans off. I did note that you said SOME and did not group all of us together. Thank you. I am a fan of many of the Idols (Clay being my favorite and I doubt even the more rabid “crazies” will ever turn me away). I really like Elliott and think he did a fine job with this song and I like his CD. I prefer the classic Clay. I also think Clay will be great on Broadway and consider comments like “he has a Broadway voice” to be a complement. Not too many mediocre voices are asked to join award winning productions. We may see Elliott there one day like Fantasia, Diana, Anthony and others. We all love the guy and are really tired of all the lies and those that just can’t stand the good and decent soul that is Clay Aiken. However, as someone else correctly said, Clay IS good enough to stand on his merits. He doesn’t need so much ‘help’.
Geegee
Nov 12, 2007 at 5:52 pm
Clay’s voice does things to me that no -one else’s can. Stops me in my tracks, it is just phenomenal. Elliot version in comparison leaves me cold, though I do like him.
Karen
Nov 13, 2007 at 5:04 am
I listened to both versions carefully, Clay`s version left me wanting to shut it off 1 minute after hitting play. I am not impressed. Clay has a great voice but seriously lacked the emotion and vocal talent needed for this piece. Elliott on the other hand owned this song. Smooth vocals, emotionally connecting to the song gave him the edge. My vote goes to Elliott Yamin.
philly
Nov 13, 2007 at 8:43 am
Just wanted to say that I voted for Clay and like I said before Elliot sings really good! But it’s that vibrato in Elliots voice that really turns me off… however I cannot deny his talent.
-philly
Nita
Nov 13, 2007 at 8:50 am
Let me state first and foremost that I am a HUGE Clay Aiken fan, but this is my least favorite of his performances. I didn’t like it when he did it in concert with Kelly either. I didn’t like them together. That being said, after listening to both of them, I guess I would say they were equal. I still would give Clay the edge, because of the strength of his gorgeous voice.
I like Elliott, he has a good voice, but this wasn’t his best either. Too much vibrato.
Like I said, Ellliott has a very good voice, …..Clay has an outstanding voice, that curls my toes, when he is really “on”. He and only “he” can make me weep, because of the beauty of his voice, and the emotion that he can express through it.
There hasn’t been another singer in this time that has affected my this way.
Open Arms belongs to Steve Perry, who is one of my all time favorites, with such a unique voice. I miss him.
bebe
Nov 13, 2007 at 9:05 am
I voted Elliot.
bebe
Nov 13, 2007 at 9:07 am
I am not a “fan” of either, but listened to both videos. Clay is off key at times. I don’t like his phasing. Elliot has a very nice vibrato as do all Great Vocalists.
Rachel
Nov 13, 2007 at 9:50 am
It’s Clay in a landslide. He has never been off key in his life, and I have seen him sing live more than once. That vibrato of Elliot’s is just awful, and he was so weak at the end, it was a blessing the song was over.
Elliott had some good nights on Idol, and I admire the fact that he can sing at all with his medical problems, but he was in no way ever as good as Clay Aiken, and he surely lacked stage presence on top of it.
Chris should have won that year for his excellent rocker sound. Katharine had a pretty voice and drop dead good looks. Maybe, Elliott should have been ahead of Taylor.
Just a Fan of great music
Nov 13, 2007 at 11:44 am
I am a Big Clay Aiken fan and absolutely love anything he sings. LOVE him….but I also think Elliott has a great voice and I only wish him the best.
What I hate, is these polls, that seem to bring out the worst of each fan base. If you don’t like Clay singing this song, that’s ok and the same with those that don’t care for Elliott’s version. I just hate to see both fan bases being mean to each other and saying mean things about the other singer.. I just don’t get it.
Sometimes I think they set up these polls, just to get the results we see here.
Nora
Nov 13, 2007 at 11:53 am
I come from the era of Sinatra, Como, Bennett, etc, at the risk of dating myself it doesn’t matter, my point is that a “Clay” comes along few and far between. Someone who can sing from the soul, from a pure heart, it’s something that is just there you can’t explain it but Clay has that gift. He doesn’t just reach young women like my granddaughter but older women like myself as well. He can make us dream and feel the romance, the magic again. He has a purity, a charisma when he sings, it’s beautiful. God Bless him.
psbintl
Nov 13, 2007 at 12:26 pm
Bebe,
To say Clay is off key is a misnomer! The two never go together. People may want to say many things about Clay Aiken, but in four years of listening to him sing in ANY performance he has NEVER been off key!
He has spot on perfect pitch!
If you feel the need to DISS Clay, at least DISS honestly for goodness sake!
Jen
Nov 13, 2007 at 12:36 pm
I have never heard any of the “great vocalist” having a quivering vibratto.
clara Boyer
Nov 13, 2007 at 12:55 pm
Oh my, Telling bebe she wasn’t honest would be like me saying to you “if you feel the need to be a fanATIC of Clay, as least be honest”.Bebe thinks he has been off key, thats her honest opinion . He is very talented, for sure, but I think he has been off key. I know love is blind sometimes. There are many that think he was offkey, but that’s o.k. He has all of you that thinks otherwise.
Jen
Nov 13, 2007 at 12:59 pm
Well, oh my, Clara. You may be the one for whom love is blind.
Great Vibe Girl
Nov