Idol Face Off - “Someone To Watch Over Me”
American Idol runner-ups Diana DeGarmo and Katharine McPhee both sang “Someone To Watch Over Me.”
Who really does have someone watching over them?
Diana DeGarmo
Katharine McPhee
Which One Has Someone Watching Over Them?
Tags: katharine mcphee, katharine, mcphee, american, idol, american idol, diana degarmo, video, someone to watch over me, poll, vote, idol stalker, idolstalker, stalker
Related Stories
POSTED IN: Diana DeGarmo, Idol Face Off, Katharine McPhee, Polls, Videos
11 opinions for Idol Face Off - “Someone To Watch Over Me”
Amanda
Oct 18, 2007 at 6:59 am
no contest, it’s Kat all the way
Christine
Oct 18, 2007 at 7:50 am
Diana, definitely. Kat’s performance wasn’t bad persay, and she was definitely her element genre-wise, but she played around with the melody way too much for my liking. This song is a classic, and you really have to stay true to the melody and essence of the song, which Diana did.
jean
Oct 18, 2007 at 9:52 am
Is it just me? The videos overlay each otehr and I can’t get Kat.
Must be my browser.
Lauren(lolo)
Oct 18, 2007 at 3:33 pm
Ugh. Diana sang it like she was some Joe Shmo at a bar who got up on stage and busted out singing. I could have done without hearing that.
I would have to say Kat did a better job.
jean
Oct 18, 2007 at 4:43 pm
I likes the style Diana tried to sing in, but she is just too young and her voice was too young.
Kat was OK, but her song did not have the right luster. I can’t give it to either of them this time.
It is the wrong song for both of them. Now this would have been a great song for Melinda.
keefir1
Oct 22, 2007 at 5:51 am
Kat hands down!She interpreted the song and made it her own… mature,professional job.
Diana just OK….sang it straight;hit some flat klunkers….
anonymous
Nov 6, 2007 at 9:59 am
Katherine McPhee is the most beautiful girl ever on American Idol but lord I just couldn’t stand to watch her sing. She smiled through every song not matter what the hell it was about and looked uncomfortable through more than half. Diana can definitely sing, she was never my favorite but the girl can really sing.
Sheila
Apr 26, 2008 at 5:50 pm
Diana Degarmo clearly wins this contest. She is known from American Idol for singing Someone To Watch Over Me. She is the first person who sang the song on American Idol. She won the voting for the night to advance to the next weeks show.
Update to today, definitely watch Diana Degarmo on the Fox Reality Show American Idol Extra this week. On Thursday, May 1st, Diana will perform her new single Right Back Where We Ended.
Stacey
May 5, 2008 at 7:41 pm
Diana Degarmo was interviewed by Seventeen magazine on April 28, 2008. For any new information on Diana please go to http://www.dianadegarmo.com
The article is posted below from Seventeen Magazine:
American Idol’s Diana DeGarmo is back in the spotlight, and this time it’s for a great cause. Diana is the spokesperson for CMT One Country, a volunteer group that’s all about helping individuals make a difference. This past weekend, CMT One Country joined forces with Youth Service America for Global Youth Service Day, the largest volunteering event in the world!
Diana has been really busy helping teens get involved, but she still found time to chat with Seventeen about the event. “There’s not one specific goal in mind — it’s all about community,” she said. “CMT One Country has made it so easy to get involved, and it’s great to be working with them. The community has gotten me to where I am today, and I’m so happy to be able to give back.”
Global Youth Service Day, which took place worldwide over the weekend, offered thousands of volunteer events that illustrated the importance of community service. For Diana, getting involved in the community is a great learning experience for teens. “It really makes you thankful for what you have,” she said. “You can see that a lot of people need help, and do something about it. It opens your eyes to the world.”
How cool is it when celebrities give back? What did you do this weekend for Global Youth Service Day? Tell us now!
posted by Seventeen Magazine on April 28, 2008, 3:41 PM
Julianne
May 15, 2008 at 10:48 am
Diana Degarmo has sure had a great year. In January, she was on the television series Gone Country on CMT. The show starred Bobby Brown, Diana Degarmo, Maureen McCormick, Carnie Wilson, Siscqo, Dee Snider, and Julio Iglesias, Jr. John Rich was the host of the show.
The show had many great guest stars such as Cowboy Troy and Randy Owen of the group Alabama.
Diana Degarmo has recently been in magazine interviews with Seventeen Magazine, OK Magazine, Country Weekly, and People Magazine (Country Edition)
Diana Degarmo has recently moved to Nashville and has been signed to John Rich’s production company.
Michelle
May 17, 2008 at 5:39 pm
Diana Degarmo was sure great on American Idol Extra on May 15, 2008. The episode had great interview footage with Syesha.
Diana Degarmo performed Right Back Where We Ended in the American Idol Extra Lounge. She was introduced by JD Roberto the host of the show. The crowd really loved her performance of the song.
Have an opinion? Leave a comment: