Comments on: Katharine McPhee in Atlanta Peach Magazine

By: aliricaba

aliricaba — Sat, 27 Oct 2007 19:56:04 +0000

Ok, I can understand why my first post was upsetting to you.

Thanks makes sense.

By: Queena

Queena — Sat, 27 Oct 2007 02:20:39 +0000

Look, we can agree to disagree. Because I don’t mind a healthy conversation on why Kat doesn’t appeal to everyone and why you don’t like her. With bitter American Idol fans, I can tell you that I have no problem when it comes to people who don’t like Katharine. So really, you can quit making those obvious assumptions of yours.

You’ve made your point very clear on why you don’t like Katharine. And throughout the rest of the posts in this topic, you’ve been great about explaining why. You have formulated reasons why and your eloquent in your explanations. I don’t have a problem with your opinion, but mainly just with your initial first response. You have to realize that when you start a post with:

“Just as I have always said: she took a spot away from someone else who really wanted to sing just to jump start her modeling acting carreer!
Sorry, she thinks she is all that and a bag of chips, but she is not. And everything is about showing her body, not talent.
But then again, she is just not that talented except to show off her body.”

Those are accusations and you have to understand that there are reasons why ANY fans who hear that about a celebrity they like are going to get defensive. Because really, it’s not like she graduated from American Idol and went straight to acting. She gave music a chance, and it just didn’t work for her.

By: aliricaba

aliricaba — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 04:31:51 +0000

No I don’t thank-you. And as far as who she is as a person, she is probably a nice person. I just don’t think she is talented and obviously you are so emotionally invested with her, you cannot handle that not everyone is going to like her like you.

And it’s no big whoop to me either. I was just responding to your post in which you stated you could not understand my sentiments about her.

Let us just agree to differ in regards to her talent. You think she is, I think she is not.

By: Queena

Queena — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 01:34:15 +0000

No. I just don’t understand why you use up so much energy into bringing so much negativity to her topic. Do you do this for every celebrity you dislike? Waste five minutes of your time making their fans unhappy? Just wondering.

Cuz hey, if I don’t like them. I move on to the next news topic. No big whoop.

By: aliricaba

aliricaba — Fri, 26 Oct 2007 01:18:00 +0000

Opinions are not always going to be favorable.

Are you are saying a person cannot share an opinion unless it is glowing?

By: Katharine McPhee in Peach Magazine - Gossip Rocks Forum

Katharine McPhee in Peach Magazine - Gossip Rocks Forum — Thu, 25 Oct 2007 23:37:48 +0000

[...] a surprise after all. Anyway

By: Queena

Queena — Thu, 25 Oct 2007 21:00:54 +0000

I don’t feel a need to be spinning excuses. I find Katharine to be a million times more likeable and talented than 90% of the celebrities out there.

You’re welcomed to share your opinion about her as am I. However, I just don’t understand why people feel the need to bring so much negativity into a topic of a celebrity that they don’t like. Last time I checked, negativity never made the world a better place.

By: aliricaba

aliricaba — Thu, 25 Oct 2007 20:55:42 +0000

There are still those who try out hoping talent WILL win over popularity, that is why!

Spin your excuses for her anyway you feel you need to Queena, that won’t make Katherine anymore talented.

She is just not my cup of tea and I am entitled to share my opinion here.

By: Queena

Queena — Thu, 25 Oct 2007 13:07:15 +0000

If the fact that she got to the finals of AI means nothing to you and apparently AI is nothing more than a popularity contest, then why are you so worked up about the fact that she “stole” someone’s spot?

To each his own indeed.

By: aliricaba

aliricaba — Thu, 25 Oct 2007 05:31:39 +0000

I never made any kind of statement as to how she treats her fans or whether or not she dissed AI or not.

It is just my opinion she not that good of a singer, and although she knows how to show off her body, her modeling to me in regards to her poses and facial expressions are very contrived. She is just not that believable or talented to me. That fake sultry expression above speaks for itself. She just does not have “IT” in my opinion.

And the fact that she got to the finals means absolutely nothing to me. After AI-2 that show became nothing more than a popularity contest with real talent thrown to the side!

To each his own.