Idol Stalker

My Guess for 3rd Place

by Jason on May 17th, 2006

I’m putting it out there and will almost guarantee that tonight is the end of the road for Katharine McPhee. Elliott outsang her last night, and her only shining moment was really “Somewhere Over the Rainbow”. I’ll put her performance last night on that song up there with Fantasia’s performance of “Summertime” and Clay Aiken’s “Bridge Over Troubled Water”. Katharine has amazing talent and beauty. Her biggest challenge will be deciding between the offers to take advantage of in her career now.

I think Taylor’s got this contest in the bag at this point. I just don’t believe that Elliott has the performance quality or charisma to really compete with Taylor anymore. Taylor just keeps firing on all cylinders and nailing almost every single performance. I just wish he’d be given the opportunity to work a little bit of his magic on the harmonica into a performance.

There, that’s my $.02 for now. Let’s see how it plays out.

Share This

Related Stories

• Chris Already Getting Offers
• Download American Idol Music Now
• Blake Lewis and Jordin Sparks Surprised
• That’s Okay. I Didn’t Want to be Here Anyway!
• Paula Abdul Speaks as Jerry Buss Gets Celebrity Star

POSTED IN: Results, Thinking Idol